Pay and offers
How to Negotiate a Salary Offer
Many offers have some room in them, and a polite, well-prepared question about pay is a normal part of hiring. This guide covers the preparation that keeps the conversation short and calm: a range built from several sources, a minimum you will not go below, and wording you can say out loud or send by email.
Key points
- Build your range from at least three kinds of source, and treat every figure as an estimate.
- Fix your minimum in private before the first conversation, based on your own costs and alternatives.
- If you are asked for a number early, you can ask for the role's budget or give a range you would be content with.
- When the offer arrives, thank the employer, ask for it in writing and take a day before you answer.
- If base pay cannot move, ask about a review date, leave, working pattern, start date or training.
A salary negotiation is usually two or three short exchanges, not a contest. Most of the work happens before the conversation: knowing what the role tends to pay, knowing what you need, and having a sentence ready for each likely moment.
Nothing here promises a higher offer: some employers have fixed pay bands and say so. Preparation makes sure that, where there is room, you ask for it clearly, and that you do not accept a figure you will resent in six months.
Build a range from several sources
One number from one website is a weak basis for a request. Pay data is collected in different ways, often from small samples, and it goes out of date. Use several kinds of source and look for where they overlap.
- Adverts for similar roles. Collect ten or so current adverts for the same job title, level and region that show pay. They tell you what employers are willing to print today.
- Published pay scales. Public bodies, universities and some larger employers publish grades and bands. If your target employer does, that band is the most useful figure you will find.
- People who know the field. A recruiter who places people in similar jobs, a former colleague or a professional association can often give a realistic range. Ask "what would you expect this role to pay?" and not "what do you earn?"
- Your own history. Your current pay, recent raises and any other offers show what employers have already paid for your work.
Convert the figures to one unit (hourly, monthly or annual), discard the obvious outliers and note the middle of what remains.
Decide your minimum before anyone asks
You need three figures, and only you see all of them. Your minimum is the lowest pay at which you would still say yes, worked out from your outgoings, your current pay and your alternatives. Your target is what the evidence says is fair for someone with your experience. Your opening figure sits a little above the target: high enough to leave room, low enough to defend with a reason.
Test the minimum against reality. If prices have risen since your last raise, a small increase may leave you worse off in real terms, and the raise vs inflation calculator shows by how much. The salary increase calculator turns a percentage into yearly and monthly amounts.
Who names a number first
No single rule works every time. If the advert shows a range, the question is already answered: aim for the part of the range your experience supports. If no range is given and you are asked for your expectations early, you have three honest options.
- Ask for theirs: "I'd like to understand the role fully before I settle on a figure. Is there a budget or band for it?" Many employers will tell you.
- Give a range whose lower end is a figure you would be content with, because the low end is the number people remember.
- Give one figure with a reason, when you know the going rate well and would prefer the discussion to start from your number.
Some application forms ask for your current salary. Whether an employer may ask differs between countries and regions, so check the rules where you live. If you do answer, be truthful.
Respond to the offer without deciding on the spot
When the offer comes, by phone or by email, do three things: thank them, ask for the full details in writing, and say when you will reply. A day or two is a normal request. You are not being difficult; you are reading an agreement before signing it.
Weaker
"Oh. I was hoping for a bit more than that, to be honest. Is there any chance you could go higher?"
Stronger
"Thank you, I'm really pleased to have the offer. Could you send the details in writing, including bonus, pension and leave? I'll come back to you by Thursday."
Why: The first reply reacts before you have seen the whole package and asks for "more" with no figure and no reason. The second keeps the tone warm, gets you the information you need and sets a date, so the next conversation can be specific.
Then look at the whole package: bonus, retirement contributions, leave and hours all carry value. The job offer comparison calculator adds base pay, expected bonus and benefits for two packages and shows the value per hour worked, which helps when one job expects longer weeks.
Make the counter-offer
Ask once, clearly, with a figure and a reason tied to the job. Reasons that work are about the role and your record: the scope of the job, specific experience, comparable adverts. Reasons about your own costs do not work. Your rent is real, but it gives the employer nothing to take to whoever approves the budget.
"Thanks again for the offer. I've read it through and I'd like to accept. There's one point I'd like to discuss first, which is the base salary. The offer is 52,000. Given that the role covers both the Leeds and Sheffield depots, and that I've run a two-site rota for the past three years, I was expecting something closer to 57,000. Is there room to move towards that?"
Then stop talking and let them answer. If they come back with 54,500:
"Thank you, I appreciate you looking at it. If we can also agree a salary review after six months, I'd be happy to accept at 54,500."
Negotiate things other than base pay
Pay bands can be rigid while other terms are not. If the base figure will not move, choose the one or two items below that matter most to you and ask for them specifically.
| What to ask for | How you might phrase it |
|---|---|
| A pay review date | "Could we agree a salary review at six months, with the criteria written down?" |
| Leave | "My current employer gives 28 days. Could the offer match that?" |
| Working pattern | "Could two home-working days a week be written into the offer?" |
| Start date | "I would like to start on 4 January, so I can finish my current project properly." |
| Training | "Would the company fund the second year of the diploma I am studying for?" |
Confirm it by email
Whatever is agreed in conversation, ask for it to appear in the written offer or contract before you resign from your current job. If you prefer to choose your words carefully, you can make the request itself by email.
Subject: Offer for Operations Planner
Dear Ms Lindqvist,
Thank you for the offer of the Operations Planner role at Marlowe & Tench Distribution. I enjoyed meeting the team and I would like to join.
Before I accept, I would like to ask about the base salary. The offer is 52,000. The role includes planning for two depots and out-of-hours cover, and I bring three years of running a two-site rota, plus daily use of the transport management system you are moving to. On that basis, would 57,000 be possible?
If the salary band is fixed, I would welcome a conversation about a six-month review or the leave allowance instead.
I am glad to talk it through by phone if that is easier.
Kind regards,
Tomas Okonkwo
+1 555 0143
If the answer is no
A "no" to your figure leaves the original offer standing in most cases. Ask whether anything else in the package can move, then make your decision against the minimum you set at the start. If the final figure is below it, declining is the outcome your preparation was for.
If you accept, do it warmly and without reopening the question. For weighing up everything beyond pay, see how to evaluate a job offer.
Common mistakes
- Quoting a figure taken from a single website leaves you unable to explain it when asked; gather several sources and use the range where they overlap.
- Accepting on the call because the moment feels awkward gives up your only chance to read the details; thank them, ask for the offer in writing and reply the next day.
- Justifying the request with personal costs such as rent or a loan rarely helps, because the employer needs reasons linked to the role and your record.
- Asking for "a bit more" without a number hands the choice of figure back to the employer; state the amount you want.
- Resigning from your current job on the strength of a spoken agreement is risky; wait until the revised terms appear in a written offer.
- Negotiating five things at once reads as unhappiness with the whole offer; pick the one or two that matter most.
Questions and answers
Can an employer withdraw an offer because I negotiated?
It can happen, but it is not the usual response to one polite, specific request. The risk rises with repeated demands or ultimatums. If an employer does withdraw over a single reasonable question, that tells you something about how later pay conversations there would have gone.
Should I mention another offer?
Only if it is real and you would take it. Say it plainly: you have another offer, you prefer this role, and the difference is the salary. Never invent a competing offer; you may be asked for details, and you would be starting a job on a false statement.
Is it acceptable to negotiate an entry-level salary?
Yes, though the room is often smaller, because many graduate and entry-level schemes pay everyone on the same scale. Ask whether the figure is fixed. If it is, questions about the start date, training or a review after probation are still reasonable.
How much above the offer should I ask for?
No percentage is reliable across jobs and countries. Base the figure on your range: if your sources and experience support a higher number, ask for that number and say why. A request you can justify in one sentence is stronger than one worked out from a rule of thumb.