Pay calculator
Job Offer Comparison Calculator
The offer with the higher salary is not always the one that pays more. This calculator adds base salary, the bonus you can reasonably expect and the yearly value of benefits for each offer, then divides each total by the hours involved so that a longer working week shows up in the numbers.
The formula
Formula
total yearly value = base salary + expected bonus + yearly value of benefits; value per hour worked = total yearly value ÷ (hours per week × 52)
- base salary
- fixed gross pay for the year
- expected bonus
- the bonus you realistically expect in a normal year, not the maximum
- yearly value of benefits
- what the employer-paid benefits are worth to you over a year
- hours per week
- the hours the job will take in practice
- total yearly value
- salary, bonus and benefits added together for one offer
- difference per year
- the gap between the two totals
- value per hour worked
- total yearly value ÷ hours worked in 52 weeks
Explained in full: Annual Salary to Hourly Rate Formula, Weighted Average Formula.
How to use it
Be conservative with the bonus. An advert that says "up to 15%" describes a ceiling, so enter what you would expect in an ordinary year, and enter 0 if the bonus is discretionary and you have no evidence of what is paid. A fixed payment written into the contract can go in at full value.
For benefits, count only what has a money value to you: employer pension contributions, health or life cover you would otherwise buy, a meal or travel allowance, extra paid leave. A benefit you would never use is worth nothing in this comparison. If one job brings a cost the other does not, such as a longer commute or paid parking, subtract the yearly cost from that offer's benefits figure.
Enter the hours you expect to work, not just the contract hours, if you have good reason to think they differ. The per-hour rows divide each total by those hours over 52 weeks. An offer can be ahead on the yearly total and behind per hour, or the reverse, and then the question becomes what your time is worth to you.
The headline row only tells you which total is larger. It says nothing about commute, flexibility, security or prospects. The guide on how to evaluate a job offer covers those, and a weighted average is one way to score them.
Worked example
Offer A pays 62,000 with an expected bonus of 4,000 and benefits worth 3,500 for a 40-hour week; Offer B pays 66,000 with no bonus and benefits worth 2,000 for a 45-hour week.
- Offer A total: 62,000 + 4,000 + 3,500 = 69,500.00.
- Offer B total: 66,000 + 0 + 2,000 = 68,000.00.
- Difference per year: 69,500 − 68,000 = 1,500.00, so Offer A is higher in total.
- Offer A value per hour worked: 69,500 ÷ (40 × 52) = 69,500 ÷ 2,080 = 33.41.
- Offer B value per hour worked: 68,000 ÷ (45 × 52) = 68,000 ÷ 2,340 = 29.06.
- Offer B has the higher base salary, yet it is behind on both measures once bonus, benefits and hours are counted.
What the calculator shows for these inputs:
| Total yearly value | Offer A is higher in total |
|---|---|
| Offer A total | 69,500.00 |
| Offer B total | 68,000.00 |
| Difference per year | 1,500.00 |
| Offer A value per hour worked | 33.41 |
| Offer B value per hour worked | 29.06 |
Money is only part of an offer. Commute, flexibility, job security and prospects do not appear in these totals.
Assumptions
- A unit of benefits or bonus is worth the same to you as a unit of salary.
- Both jobs are worked for 52 weeks a year at the weekly hours entered.
- Both offers are in the same currency and all amounts are gross.
Limitations
- It does not compare tax treatment; salary, bonus and benefits can be taxed differently, and the rules vary by country.
- Offers in different currencies or countries cannot be compared here, because no exchange rate or cost of living is applied.
- Share options, sign-on payments and other one-off or uncertain items have no field of their own.
- Leave allowance, commute, flexibility, job security and prospects are not in the totals.
Questions and answers
How do I put a value on benefits?
Use what the employer pays where you know it, such as a pension contribution as a percentage of salary, and what you would pay yourself for things like health cover. Convert everything to a yearly amount. Leave out benefits you would not use, and do not count the same thing in both salary and benefits.
What should I enter for a bonus that is not certain?
Enter the amount you would expect in a typical year, based on what the employer tells you about recent payouts. If you cannot find out, try the comparison twice, once with 0 and once with the target amount, and see whether the answer changes.
Why can an offer win on total value but lose per hour?
Because the per-hour figure divides by the working week. If the 45-hour job in the example were 40 hours, its value per hour would rise from 29.06 to 32.69. Long hours can cancel out a higher salary.
Can I compare a permanent job with a contract role?
Yes, with care. First turn the contract into a yearly figure with the day rate calculator, subtract the costs you would bear yourself, and enter the result as base salary with benefits set to match what the contract really includes, which is often 0.
What if the two totals are very close?
Then money should not decide it. A gap of 1,500 a year in the example is about 2% of either total, well within the uncertainty of a bonus estimate. Let the factors outside the calculator, such as the work itself, the manager and the commute, carry the decision.