Pay and offers
How to Evaluate a Job Offer
An offer is more than a salary figure, and the parts that decide whether you are still glad in a year are often the hardest to put a number on. This guide gives you a list of what to look at, questions to ask before you answer, and a simple scoring method for comparing an offer with your current job or with a second offer.
Key points
- Ask for the full offer and contract in writing, and read every page before you say yes.
- Compare total yearly value and value per hour worked, not base salary alone.
- Find out who your manager will be and how the team works, because that shapes most working days.
- Score each option against your own weighted criteria to see what your instincts are reacting to.
- Take contract clauses you do not understand to a qualified adviser before you sign.
The day an offer arrives is the day you have the most freedom to ask questions and the least inclination to, because relief takes over. Slow down for a day. Thank the employer, ask for the offer and the contract in writing, and tell them when you will reply.
Then work through the areas below. You are looking for two things: anything that would make you turn the job down, and anything you would want changed or clarified before you accept.
Start with the whole package
Base salary is one line. Add the expected bonus (and ask how often it has been paid in full), employer retirement contributions, health cover, allowances, shares and paid leave. Then subtract what the job costs you: travel, parking, childcare for longer days, equipment you must buy.
Take two fictional offers. Northgate Freight offers a base of 54,000, an expected bonus of 3,000 and benefits worth 2,500 a year, for a 37.5-hour week. Pell & Marsh offers 60,000, no bonus and benefits worth 1,500, for a 45-hour week. The totals are 59,500 and 61,500, so the second pays 2,000 more a year. Per hour worked, though, the first is worth about 30.51 and the second about 26.28. The job offer comparison calculator does this arithmetic with your own figures.
What reaches your bank account depends on tax and other deductions, which differ by country and by personal circumstances. Use an official calculator for your country, or the take-home pay estimator with rates you enter yourself, before you compare monthly budgets.
Hours, workload and flexibility
Contracted hours and real hours are often different. Ask what a normal week looks like, how often evenings or weekends are needed, whether overtime is paid or given back as time off, and how on-call duty works if there is any. Put these questions to the people who would be your colleagues as well as to the hiring manager.
Check the flexibility that matters to you in particular: fixed or variable start times, the freedom to swap shifts, how leave is approved, and whether part-time or compressed hours have ever been agreed for someone in the team.
Growth and what you will learn
Ask what the last person in the role went on to do, what training budget or study leave exists, and how performance and pay are reviewed. A job that pays slightly less but gives you a skill, a qualification or a level of responsibility you lack may be worth more over five years than the difference in salary. A team where nobody has moved up in years tells you something as well.
The manager and the team
Your manager shapes your workload, your feedback and your chances of progression, so try to meet them before accepting if you have not already. Useful things to ask: how they like to be kept informed, what a good first six months would look like, and why the previous person left. There are more in the guide to questions to ask an interviewer.
Notice how the employer has behaved so far. Were interviews on time? Did people do what they said they would? Does the written offer match what was discussed? The hiring process is a small sample of how the organisation works.
Commute and remote terms
Time the commute door to door at the hour you would really travel, and multiply it by the days per week. An extra 40 minutes each way, four days a week, is more than five hours of every week.
For remote or hybrid roles, find out whether the arrangement is written into the contract or is a current policy that could change, which days are fixed, who pays for equipment and for travel to the office, and whether pay is tied to where you live.
Contract terms to read slowly
Read the written contract itself, not somebody's description of it. Employment law differs widely between countries, and this guide cannot tell you what is enforceable where you live. What it can do is list the clauses that deserve a careful second reading.
- Probation. How long it lasts, what notice applies during it and what changes when it ends.
- Notice period. How much you must give and how much you would receive. A long notice period affects how quickly you could take a future job.
- Hours and place of work. Whether the employer can change your location, shifts or duties, and with how much warning.
- Bonus and commission. Whether they are contractual or discretionary, how they are calculated, and what happens to them if you leave part-way through the year.
- Restrictions after leaving. Clauses that limit working for competitors or contacting clients, and any requirement to repay training or relocation costs.
- Conditions. Whether the offer depends on references, background checks or proof of qualifications, and what happens if those are delayed.
Score the options against your own priorities
When two options are close, a weighted score makes your reasoning visible. List what matters to you, give each item a weight so that the weights total 100, then score each option from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). Multiply each score by its weight, add the results and divide by 100.
| Criterion | Weight | Offer A score | Offer B score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total pay and benefits | 30 | 4 | 5 |
| Hours and flexibility | 20 | 3 | 2 |
| Growth and learning | 20 | 5 | 3 |
| Manager and team | 15 | 4 | 3 |
| Commute or remote terms | 10 | 2 | 4 |
| Security and contract terms | 5 | 4 | 4 |
| Weighted score out of 5 | 100 | 3.80 | 3.55 |
Offer A: (30 × 4 + 20 × 3 + 20 × 5 + 15 × 4 + 10 × 2 + 5 × 4) ÷ 100 = 3.80. Offer B comes to 3.55, although it pays more. The weighted average calculator will do the sum if you enter the scores and the weights in the same order.
The score is an aid to thinking, not a verdict. If the result disappoints you, that reaction is information: either a weight is wrong, or something you care about is missing from the list. Add your current job as a third column, since staying is one of the options too.
Give your answer
If you want changes, ask for them once and together; the guide to negotiating a salary offer has wording for that. If you accept, do so in writing, and wait for the signed contract and any conditions to be cleared before you hand in your notice. If you decline, a short and courteous reply keeps the relationship intact.
Subject: Payroll Supervisor offer
Dear Mr Adeyemi,
Thank you for offering me the Payroll Supervisor role, and for the time you and the team gave me over the past three weeks. After careful thought I have decided not to accept. I have chosen a role closer to home that suits my family commitments better.
I was impressed by the finance team at Pell & Marsh and I hope our paths cross again.
Kind regards,
Ioana Dumitrescu
Common mistakes
- Comparing base salaries only hides differences in bonus, retirement contributions, leave and hours; add up the full yearly value of each option.
- Accepting by phone before seeing the contract can leave you bound to a clause on hours or location that was never mentioned; ask for the documents first.
- Taking a described bonus at face value is a common error; ask how it is calculated and what was paid in recent years.
- Ignoring the commute because the salary is higher overlooks travel time and cost that may cancel out the increase.
- Giving notice before references, checks and other conditions of the new offer have cleared puts both jobs at risk.
- Leaving your present job out of the comparison means the new offer is judged against nothing; score staying put as one of the options.
Questions and answers
How long can I take to answer a job offer?
No fixed rule applies. Asking for two or three working days is common and reasonable, and longer if you are still waiting for the written contract. Give the employer the date you will reply by and keep to it; silence worries them more than a clear request for time.
What if I am waiting to hear from another employer?
Tell the second employer that you hold an offer and ask whether they can decide by a certain date. Ask the first for a short extension if you need one. Avoid accepting one offer while intending to withdraw later: it damages trust and may have contractual consequences.
Should I accept a lower salary for a better job?
It can be a sound choice if the role gives you skills, hours or prospects you value and the lower figure still covers your needs. Work out the monthly difference after deductions so you know exactly what you are giving up, then decide whether what you gain is worth that amount to you.
Can I ask to speak to future colleagues before deciding?
Yes. Many employers will arrange a short call or visit if you ask once the offer is made. A conversation with someone doing a similar job is one of the best ways to learn about real hours, workload and how the manager behaves day to day.