Job search

How to Work With Recruiters

Recruiters can open doors, but they work for employers, not for you. This guide explains the two main kinds of recruiter, how agencies are usually paid, what to tell them and ask them, and how to keep control of where your resume is sent.

Key points

  • Remember that both in-house and agency recruiters act for the employer, and treat every conversation as part of the assessment.
  • Expect the employer to pay the agency; be cautious of anyone who asks a job seeker for a fee, and check the rules where you live.
  • Give recruiters a clear target, your availability and a pay range, and tell them where you have already applied.
  • Insist on being told the employer and role, and on agreeing, before your resume is sent anywhere.
  • Keep applying directly as well, because agencies only see the vacancies their clients give them.

"Recruiter" covers two different jobs. One recruiter is employed by the organisation you want to join. The other works for an agency that employers pay to find candidates. Both can help you, and neither works for you, which is the most useful thing to remember in every dealing with them.

Recruitment practices and regulations differ between countries and industries. Treat what follows as the common pattern, and check local rules wherever money or contracts are involved.

In-house and agency recruiters

Point of comparisonIn-house recruiterAgency recruiter
Employed byThe hiring employerA recruitment agency or search firm
Fills jobs atOne organisationMany client employers
Usually paidA salary from the employerBy the employer, often as a fee when a candidate is hired
KnowsThe team, the process and the budget in detailThe local market and several employers, in varying depth
Useful to you forAccurate information about this vacancy and its processVacancies you may not see advertised, and a view of the market

In-house recruiters, sometimes called talent acquisition, run the process. They screen applications, arrange interviews and often make the offer. What you say to them reaches the hiring manager.

Agency recruiters sit between you and the employer. A good one will brief you on the role, help you prepare for the interview and handle the discussion of the offer. A poor one will send your resume widely and tell you little.

How agencies are usually paid

In most arrangements the employer pays the agency and the candidate pays nothing. A common model is a fee that is due only if the agency's candidate is hired, often worked out from the starting salary. For senior or specialist roles an employer may instead retain a single search firm and pay for the search itself. For temporary and contract work, the agency typically charges the client a rate and pays the worker out of it.

This explains a lot of agency behaviour. The recruiter earns when a placement is made, so there is a reason to move quickly, to put forward candidates who closely match the brief and to see an offer accepted. Those interests overlap with yours a good deal, but not completely.

What to tell a recruiter

A recruiter can match you to roles only with clear, accurate information. Give them:

  • The role titles and level you are aiming for, and what you would not consider.
  • Locations, working pattern and when you could start, including your notice period.
  • The pay range you are looking for. You can state expectations without disclosing your current pay; in some places employers and recruiters are restricted from asking about salary history, and rules vary.
  • Which employers you have already applied to or been put forward to, so that nothing is duplicated.
  • Any constraint that could surface later, such as a booked holiday, a visa condition or a restrictive clause in your contract.

Be open about other processes you are in. You need not name the employers, but "I have a second interview elsewhere next week" helps a recruiter judge timing. Assume that anything you say may be passed to the client, so be honest and be measured.

What to ask a recruiter

  • Who is the employer? If the recruiter will not say before sending your resume, ask why, and consider declining.
  • Are you working with this employer directly, and are other agencies working on the same vacancy?
  • What is the salary range, and what is the working pattern?
  • Why is the role open, and how long has it been vacant?
  • What does the process involve, and over what timescale?
  • What might make the client hesitate about my resume?

Ask that last question every time. A recruiter who knows the client will give a direct answer, and it tells you what to address at interview.

Stay in control of where your resume goes

The main risk with agencies is losing track of who has your resume. If two agencies put you forward for the same vacancy, or an agency submits you somewhere you have already applied, the employer can face a dispute over who is owed the fee. Some employers drop the candidate to avoid it.

Make one rule clear at the start: nobody sends your resume to any employer without telling you the employer's name and getting your agreement for that specific role.

Message setting the ground rules

Hi Priya,

Thanks for the call today. I am happy for you to represent me for the Operations Analyst role at Ashby Cross Freight Services, and I confirm that I have not applied there or been put forward by anyone else.

For any other vacancy, please tell me the employer and the role and wait for my reply before you send my resume. I am keeping a record of where it has gone so that there are no duplicate submissions.

Could you also let me know when you have submitted it and when you expect to hear back?

Thanks,
Tomasz Wieczorek

Then keep that record. In your job application tracker, log each submission with the agency, the recruiter's name and the date, just as you would a direct application. If the agency reformats your resume or asks for a Word version, ask to see what will be sent.

When a recruiter contacts you first

Unsolicited messages are common once you have a profile on a professional networking site; how to write an online professional profile explains how to make yours easy to find. A message deserves a reply if it names a real role and gives enough detail to judge it.

Reply to a recruiter's first message

Hi Marcus,

Thank you for getting in touch. I am open to hearing more. Before we arrange a call, could you send me the job description, the name of the employer, the salary range and whether the role is on site, hybrid or remote?

For context, I am looking for senior QA roles in Dublin or remote within Ireland, and my notice period is one month.

Best regards,
Aoife Brennan

If the recruiter cannot share a description or a range after that, you have lost nothing. If the role is not for you, say so in one line. Recruiters remember candidates who answer clearly, and the next role may fit.

Keep the relationship working

Reply promptly, turn up to what you agree to, and give honest feedback after each interview. If you accept a job elsewhere or change your mind about a role, tell the recruiter the same day. When an offer comes through an agency, the recruiter usually carries the negotiation, so decide your figures beforehand with the help of how to negotiate a salary offer and state them plainly.

Do not hand your whole search to agencies. They cover only the vacancies their clients give them. Keep applying directly and talking to people you know, as set out in how to plan a job search.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming an agency recruiter is your personal agent leads to disappointment; they are paid by the employer, so manage your own search alongside.
  • Letting several agencies send your resume freely can produce duplicate submissions; require your agreement for each employer and role.
  • Being vague about pay and availability results in unsuitable roles; give a clear range, your notice period and your limits at the first call.
  • Hiding that you have already applied to an employer directly causes disputes later; tell the recruiter before they submit you.
  • Going silent when you lose interest in a role damages the relationship; send a one-line message saying you are withdrawing.
  • Paying a fee to be put forward for a vacancy without checking local rules exposes you to scams; verify with an official source first.

Questions and answers

Do I have to pay a recruitment agency?

In the usual arrangement, no: the employer pays the agency. Rules on charging job seekers vary by country, and in many places it is restricted. Treat any request for an upfront fee with caution and check an official source for the position where you live.

Can I work with more than one agency at once?

Yes, and many people do. The condition is that you keep a careful record of which agency has sent your resume to which employer, and that you tell each recruiter where you have already been put forward, so no vacancy receives you twice.

Should I tell a recruiter my current salary?

You can choose to state the range you are seeking instead. Whether a recruiter may ask about pay history depends on local rules, which vary. Giving your expectations and the reasoning behind them is usually enough for a recruiter to judge whether a role fits.

Why did a recruiter stop replying to me?

Most often the client filled the role, changed the brief or paused hiring, and the recruiter moved on to other vacancies. It is poor practice but common. Send one short message asking for an update, then continue your search through other channels.

Is it better to apply directly or through an agency?

If the employer advertises the role itself, applying directly is simple and keeps you in control. If the vacancy is only available through an agency, use the agency. Do not do both for the same vacancy, because that creates a duplicate.