Ideal Body Weight Formulas Compared: Devine, Robinson, Miller and the Healthy BMI Range
"Ideal weight" formulas were not created to tell you what you should weigh. They were developed for medical purposes such as drug dosing and later became popular as weight targets. Knowing their origin helps you use them sensibly.
Open the Ideal Weight Calculator
Where the formulas came from
The Devine formula (1974) was designed to estimate dosing for medications, not to define a perfect body. The Robinson (1983), Miller (1983) and Hamwi (1964) formulas are variations built on similar ideas. All take height as the main input and add a fixed amount of weight for every inch above 5 feet, with different starting weights for men and women.
The formulas
| Formula | Men (kg) | Women (kg) |
|---|---|---|
| Devine | 50 + 2.3 per inch over 5 ft | 45.5 + 2.3 per inch over 5 ft |
| Robinson | 52 + 1.9 per inch over 5 ft | 49 + 1.7 per inch over 5 ft |
| Miller | 56.2 + 1.41 per inch over 5 ft | 53.1 + 1.36 per inch over 5 ft |
| Hamwi | 48 + 2.7 per inch over 5 ft | 45.4 + 2.27 per inch over 5 ft |
Worked example: 170 cm (about 66.9 inches)
That is 6.9 inches above 5 feet. Using the Devine formula, a man would get 50 + 2.3 × 6.9 = 65.9 kg and a woman 45.5 + 2.3 × 6.9 = 61.4 kg. Robinson gives 65.2 kg and 60.8 kg. The formulas disagree by several kilograms, which tells you the "ideal" is more of a region than a point.
Ideal weight versus the healthy range
The BMI-based range for the same height (18.5 to 24.9) is 53.5 kg to 72.0 kg, a span of about 18 kg. The formula results above fall inside it. Because the BMI range reflects health data across large populations, many clinicians prefer it to a single formula figure, and it does not assume a particular body frame.
Limits
- None of the formulas consider age, muscle mass, bone structure or fat distribution.
- They were derived from limited and mostly older datasets.
- They are less reliable for very tall or very short people, and for athletes.
- Your healthiest weight may differ from any formula depending on your health and how you feel at that weight.
Using the result
Use the output to see a reasonable zone, not to set a rigid target. Notice how you feel, how your clothes fit, your energy, sleep and fitness, and whether markers such as blood pressure and blood sugar are healthy. A doctor or dietitian can help set a realistic goal if you want to change weight.
Common mistakes
- Treating a formula as a medical standard.
- Mixing metric and imperial values.
- Aiming for the lowest figure in a range.
- Ignoring muscle mass when interpreting the results.
Frequently asked questions
Which formula is best?
None is universally best. They differ because they were designed from different data. Averaging them, or using the BMI range, reduces the dependence on any single formula.
Why is the result lower for women?
The women's formulas start from a lower base weight, reflecting average differences in height-matched body composition. Individual variation is far larger than the gap.
Does ideal weight change with age?
The formulas do not adjust for age. Healthy weight ranges can shift as people get older, so discuss targets with a professional.
Keep reading
- Use the Ideal Weight Calculator
- BMI Calculator: guide
- Body Fat Calculator: guide
- BMR Calculator: guide
- Calorie Calculator: guide
This guide is general information, not medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Talk to a qualified healthcare professional about your own situation. See our disclaimer.