Cover letters
Common Cover Letter Mistakes and How to Fix Them
Most cover letter problems fall into a handful of patterns: the letter repeats the resume, could be sent to anyone, talks about the wrong things or contains an avoidable slip. This guide shows each pattern with a corrected version, then gives a short routine for checking your own draft.
Key points
- Write to two or three requirements from the advert and leave your career history to the resume.
- Apply the swap test: if a rival employer's name would fit the letter equally well, add something specific.
- Replace every adjective about yourself with a fact, or delete it.
- Check all names, titles and dates against the advert before sending.
- Read the finished letter aloud to catch stiff, apologetic or boastful sentences.
A cover letter rarely fails because of one dramatic error. It fails because it gives the reader nothing they did not already have: no new information, no evidence, no sign that it was written for them.
The patterns below are ordered roughly by how much damage they do. Each has a fix you can apply to a draft today.
The letter repeats the resume
The most familiar pattern is a letter that walks through the applicant's career in order: where they studied, their first job, their second. The reader has that information one click away, laid out more clearly.
Weaker
I graduated in 2019 and joined Sable Street Analytics as a junior analyst. In 2022 I was promoted to analyst, and I have worked on reporting, dashboards and client presentations.
Stronger
Your advert asks for someone who can turn retail data into decisions. At Sable Street Analytics I rebuilt a grocery client's weekly sales dashboard so that store managers could see stock shortfalls by Tuesday, not the following Monday.
Why: The first version is a timeline. The second picks one requirement from the advert and answers it with one piece of work, which is something only a letter can do.
Fix: choose two or three requirements and write to those. Leave the chronology to the resume.
The letter could be sent to anyone
Readers recognise a mass-mailed letter by what it lacks: nothing about the role beyond its title, nothing about the organisation beyond its name. Try the swap test. Replace the employer's name with a rival's; if the letter still reads correctly, it is generic.
Weaker
I have long admired your company's reputation for excellence and would be proud to contribute to your continued success.
Stronger
I have been a customer of Kestrel Row Bakery since the Hythe Street shop opened, and I would like to help run the wholesale side you launched this spring.
Why: The strong version contains two facts about this employer and one about the writer's connection to it. It could not be pasted into a letter to anyone else.
Fix: one specific, true sentence about the employer's work, placed where you explain why you are applying. The cover letter examples each include a paragraph of this kind.
It is about what you want
Sentences about how the job would help your career ("this role would let me develop my skills") are honest but aimed at the wrong reader. An employer is hiring to get work done. Your growth matters to them mainly as a sign that you will stay and improve.
Fix: turn each "I want" into "I can". "I am keen to gain experience in budgeting" becomes "I have managed an events budget of 12,000 for the students' union and want to do the same at a larger scale." One sentence about your own aims, near the end, is plenty.
Claims without evidence
Adjectives are free, so readers discount them. Anyone can write that they are hard-working, and almost everyone does. A claim earns belief only when a fact stands behind it.
| Stock phrase | Why it fails | What to write instead |
|---|---|---|
| I am a hard-working team player | True of most applicants and unprovable on the page | One thing you did with a team, and the result |
| I am passionate about customer service | Names a feeling, not a behaviour | What you do for customers that others skip |
| I believe I would be a great fit | That is the reader's decision to make | The two requirements you meet most clearly |
| I have excellent communication skills | The letter itself is the evidence, for better or worse | A presentation, report or negotiation you handled |
| I am a fast learner | Asks for trust in place of experience | Something you learned quickly, and how long it took |
Wrong or leftover details
These are small and they are costly, because they are noticed immediately and suggest carelessness about everything else.
- The previous employer's name is left in the last paragraph after a copy and paste.
- The role title does not match the advert, or belongs to a different vacancy.
- The recipient's name is misspelt, or the wrong title is used.
- The date is from the last time the letter was sent.
- The file name reveals the letter's history, such as
cover-letter-harlow-finch-EDITED.pdfsent to another firm.
Fix: search the document for every proper noun and check each against the advert. Then proofread the whole letter with the same slow methods you would use on a resume; the guide to proofreading a resume describes them.
The tone is off
Tone goes wrong in two directions. Some letters apologise: "Although I do not have direct experience..." hands the reader a reason to stop. Others oversell: "I am confident I am the best candidate you will meet" makes a claim nobody can verify, least of all the writer.
Stiffness is a milder version of the same problem. "I wish to submit my candidature to your esteemed organisation" sounds like nobody. Write as you would speak to a senior colleague you respect: full sentences, plain words, no slang.
Fix: read the letter aloud. Rewrite any sentence you would be embarrassed to say across a desk.
Layout and length problems
A letter that runs to two pages, uses a different font from the resume or arrives as an oddly named file creates friction before a word is read. These are quick to put right: the guides to cover letter format and cover letter length give the settings and word counts.
A ten-minute repair routine
- Highlight every sentence that also appears, in substance, on your resume. Cut or replace half of them.
- Underline each adjective you apply to yourself. For each one, add the fact that supports it or delete the adjective.
- Run the swap test on the paragraph about the employer.
- Check the employer's name, the role title, the recipient's name and the date against the advert.
- Read the letter aloud once, start to finish.
- Tick through the cover letter checklist before you attach the file.
If the draft needs more than repairs, it may be quicker to start again from the five-part structure in how to write a cover letter.
Common mistakes
- Ignoring instructions in the advert, such as a reference number to quote or questions to answer in the letter, which is an easy reason for an application to be set aside.
- Criticising a current or former employer to explain why you are leaving, which makes the reader wonder what you would say about them; give a forward-looking reason.
- Raising salary, holidays or working hours when the advert has not asked, which spends limited space on terms before the employer has decided to talk to you.
- Explaining personal circumstances at length, such as health or family history, when a single neutral line about a gap or a move is all the reader needs.
- Relying on a spellchecker alone, which will not notice a correctly spelt wrong word or the wrong company name; ask someone else to read the letter if you can.
Questions and answers
Will one typo get my application rejected?
Nobody can say how a particular reader will react. Some will overlook a single slip and others will not, especially for roles where accuracy is part of the job. Since you cannot know which reader you will get, treat every error as one to fix before sending.
Is it a mistake to use a template?
No. A template for the layout saves time and keeps the letter tidy. The mistake is templated wording: sentences taken from a sample and sent unchanged. Use a template for structure and write the content from your own experience and the advert in front of you.
Should I explain a weakness or a gap in the cover letter?
Only if the reader would otherwise be confused, for example by a long recent gap or a change of field. Deal with it in one plain sentence and move straight to what you offer. Detailed explanations are better kept for an interview, if they are asked for at all.
Is a funny or unusual cover letter a mistake?
It is a risk. Humour depends on the reader's taste and mood, and you know neither. In creative fields a distinctive voice can help, but even there the letter still has to show that you understand the job and can do it.